Friday, February 6, 2015

Redefining "Race"

It’s a fact that we are all different, and we always will be -- and this is a good thing. The word “race” has definitely retained a fairly dirty history, however, this doesn’t mean we should do away with the term all together, as Montagu proposed. Given our human ability to analyze differences in each other, we will always find some way to split ourselves into differing sects of the same species, however, this doesn’t have to be an issue of superiority as it has for so long. I agree with Locke in the notion that “race” can still be used to promote our differences in a positive way without tainting our relations with one another. While I agree with Locke’s idea of redefining the way we think about and use race, I still think he discredits a few important distinctions race can make between us. Locke seems to want to treat race purely as a cultural distinction as opposed to a biological distinction. I can mostly agree with this, however, I can’t tell if he’s wanting to exclude any kind of aesthetic distinctions between races in this proposed revision. I agree that purely aesthetic distinctions between humans can’t accurately account for a ‘solid’ method of identifying our differences, as we are much more complex than that, however, our physical differences should still be held as significant if we want to truly endorse what makes us unique. We are not purely defined by our appearances; however, to disregard the way we look is to ignore a part of who we are. Both physical and mental traits should be taken into account when defining any given individual, and thus, when defining a vast cluster of humans, we should not only take the cultural aspects of these peoples into account, but the physical distinctions that set them apart as well. I believe diversity should set us apart in order to bring us back together.  Diversity is something that should be cherished, as it’s not just what we all hold in common that makes our relations so beautiful, but what makes us different. 

1 comment:

  1. You know, there is something to be said about being in a place where everyone looks like you. As part of a minority, there is this weird uncomfortable feeling that sometimes comes in when I walk into a room and I realize that I am the only poc there. It's comforting to be in a predominantly or even exclusively hispanic area. The origins of race are certainly shitty, but for the rest of our lifetimes and probably our children's, the idea will continue to be there.

    I agree that diversity is something we should strive for, because representation is important. It doesn't have to be about superiority, you're right. We'd have to strive very hard to shake off the old mentality, but maybe we could form a world where we are happy in each other's differences instead of hostile.

    And because I just really really love Star Trek, I'm going to leave these two quotes right here:

    "The glory of creation is in its infinite diversity."
    "And in the way our differences combine to create meaning and beauty."
    -- Dr. Miranda Jones and Spock, "Is There in Truth No Beauty?"

    "Alexander, where I come from, size, shape or color makes no difference. And nobody has the power." -- Captain Kirk, "Plato's Stepchildren."

    ReplyDelete